Eyewitness and Crusade Narrative

Eyewitness and Crusade Narrative

Perception and Narration in Accounts of the Second, Third and Fourth Crusades

Marcus Bull


Boydell Press



The idea of what an "eyewitness" account is here scrutinised through examination of key Crusading texts.
"Eyewitness" is a familiar label that historians apply to numerous pieces of evidence. It carries compelling connotations of trustworthiness and particular proximity to the lived experience of historical actors. But it has received surprisingly little critical attention.
This book seeks to open up discussion of what we mean when we label a historical source in this way. Through a close analysis of accounts of the Second, Third and Fourth Crusades, as well as an in-depth discussion of recent research by cognitive and social psychologists into perception and memory, this book challenges historians of the Middle Ages to revisit their often unexamined assumptions about the place of eyewitness narratives within the taxonomies of historical evidence. It is for the most part impossible to situate the authors of the texts studied here, viewed as historical actors, in precise spatial and temporal relation to the action that they purport to describe. Nor can we ever be truly certain what they actually saw. In what, therefore, does the authors' eyewitness status reside, and is this, indeed, a valid category of analysis?
This book argues that the most productive way in which to approach the figure of the autoptic author is not as some floating presence close to historical events, validating our knowledge of them, but as an artefact of the text's meaning-making operations, in particular as these are opened up to scrutiny by narratological concepts such as the narrator, focalization and storyworld. The conclusion that emerges is that there is no single understanding of eyewitness running through the texts, for all their substantive and thematic similarities; each fashions its narratorial voice in different ways as a function of its particular story-telling strategies.

MARCUS BULL is Andrew W Mellon Distinguished Professor of Medieval and Early Modern Studies at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

An e-book version of this title is available (9781787443433), to libraries through a number of trusted suppliers. See here for a full list of our partners.


September 2018
406 pages
23.4x15.6 cm
Crusading in Context
ISBN: 9781783273355
Format: Hardback
Boydell Press
BIC HBLC1, 1D, 2AB, 3H
Share on Facebook   Share on Twitter   Pin it   Share by Email

Table of Contents

Introduction: Medieval and Modern Approaches to Eyewitnessing and Narratology as an Analytical Tool
Memory and Psychological Research into Eyewitnessing
The Second Crusade: The De Expugnatione Lyxbonensi and Odo of Deuil's De Profectione Ludovici VII in Orientem
The Third Crusade: Ambroise's Estoire de la Guerre Sainte and Points of Comparison and Contrast
Geoffrey of Villehardouin's and Robert of Clari's Narratives of the Fourth Crusade

Author Bio

Andrew W Mellon Distinguished Professor of Medieval and Early Modern Studies, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

Also by Author